Edward C. Whitmont, MD
Alchemy of Healing: Psyche and Soma by EDWARD C. WHITMONT MD
This book review is reprinted with permission from Homeopathic Links (Homoeopathic Links – Summer 1994)
Reviewed by Misha Norland
These words by Whitmont are an example of the challenge which his 81 years of experience of the human condition, his enquiry and his wisdom, hold in store for the reader. Once again taking up the torch which C. G. Jung handed to him, and which gave rise to the lectures and subsequent book, Psyche and Substance, Whitmont has penned us a volume out of his depth of experience, and offers us the fruits of searching beneath the surface of things to find ‘hidden’ meanings and, in particular, the book pays attention to and honours, the principles of homoeopathy. His sources range from Aristotle to the alchemists, as well as classical and modern writers and poets, and include the data of the ‘new’ physics, the findings of biologists and analytical psychologists. Myths, stories and case histories are interpreted with subtlety. The book is well referenced and contains many quotes refering to the tradition of human enquiry, to Eastern as well as Western thought and religion. Occasionally it is well to read a paragraph over a few times in order that the full meaning may emerge! As each cell is to the body, so each individual and their particular process (including their pathologising) is a part of the body and destiny of the Earth. Thus Whitmont’s vision includes an understanding of disease in terms of ‘divine’ entelechy.
I find myself in total accord with Whitmont’s speculations, however there are aspects of his appreciation of how homoeopathy works which I question. For example on page 105 it is stated: The substance-derived field [of the homoeopathic remedy, Ed] addresses itself directly to biological or somatic code systems and may secondarily affect psychological, emotional and mental functioning. The reverse is true of psychic induction, which operates from the psychic to the somatic. I have observed from my practice and also from homoeopathic provings that such distinctions do not in fact occur; that the influence produces discernible changes at whichever level . I should also comment that the general level of homoeopathic, and in particular materia medica, insight is less than the otherwise very high level of philosophical and psychological understanding. In conclusion, although The Alchemy of Healing would be a book more accessible to the reader of psychological literature rather than the ‘just’ homoeopath, the ‘just’ homoeopath would benefit enormously. Let us give the last words to Whitmont. “In the core of what eventually manifests as illness and pathology is encoded the universally human ‘basic fault’ (as the experience of a frightened and traumatised child with its sense of helplessness, shame and anger in the face of what is felt to be overwhelming odds). In the midst of all the fault lines, whirlpools, eddies and dissipative forces of our earth and the cosmo-embedded flow of our life stream, our sense of individual identity remains vested in the reality of our early childbody selves that persists in everybody, hidden behind defences and rational insights. While basically afraid and frightened by previous wounding, this childbody self is also that which wants and is able to grow. It strives to reconstruct itself, to be reborn out of the misery, ‘mortification’ and apparent senselessness of every suffered conflict, every seeming ‘no exit’ impasse. It responds to the call of its entelechy and – whether we realise it consciously or not strives to mature and grow through the wisdom extracted from the experience of being tossed about, succussed’, shaken and carried by the stream of life’ through the phases of sorrow and joy, death and birth”.